Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase through one of these links, The TCG Times may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
How’s this? One big card makes up about 71% of everything in OP-09 and that card is to no ones suprise is the Manga Gol D. Roger. Currently, one is listed at roughly $30,000 USD… raw! Considering the whole set’s total value is worth about $42,000 USD, that’s a hefty slice of the pie. Have a closer look, and you realise there are only four copies for sale, and the cheapest one is around $8,500 USD. Meanwhile, the Alternate Art version of the very same Roger sells for only a mere $50 USD… Same character, same set and a massive 600x price gap. So where does the sensible long-term money go? That’s here to do today!
How We Judge “Long Term”
OP-09 launched in December 2024, so this is a mature, almost two-year-old set, meaning it has sales data from the past 2 years we can use to inform fair investment concepts and conclusions. We use three tests based on this data and, as always, borrow from our four pillars of card value resource. So what are we testing? The main categories are character demand will people still want this character in five years?, scarcity inside the set how few copies exist compared with the cards around it?, and reprint risk and originality (could Bandai print this again, and is the art one of a kind?). A card has to pass all three to be something truly considered a long-term investment.

The Scoreboard
Here are the five most valuable cards in the set, from our data:
| Card | Price now | Share of set value |
|---|---|---|
| Gol D. Roger (Manga) | $27,000–$30,000 | 71% |
| Monkey D. Luffy (Manga) | $2,450–$2,725 | 6% |
| Marshall D. Teach (Manga) | $1,700–$1,850 | 4% |
| Shanks (Manga) | $1,200–$1,800 | 4% |
| Buggy (Manga) | $1,000–$1,500 | 4% |
| Everything else (about 157 cards) | about $4,300 combined | 10% |
So five Manga cards make up about 90% of the set’s total value, and the Manga rarity ironically could be considered the “one pieces” of this set, with only 4 to 13 copies of each for sale. Their price tags are also pretty darn unreliable, for example, Roger’s “market price” is about $30,000 USD, but the cheapest copy is about $8,500 USD. Just so we are all on the same page, the market price is an estimate from recent sales, while the lowest listing is what you’d pay today. When they are as far apart as in the Roger case we are discussing, treat the market price with suspicion. These are lottery tickets, not where we’d put long-term money.
The Ride So Far
Here’s one year of price history on the cards we’re weighing, plus the booster box:
| Card | Nov 2025 | Peak | Now |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gol D. Roger Alternate Art | about $58 | about $118 (Jan) | about $50 |
| Luffy (119) Alternate Art | about $22 | about $64 (Jan) | about $30 |
| Shanks Wanted Poster | about $170 | about $300 (Feb) | about $220 |
| Teach Wanted Poster | about $95 | about $258 (Aug) | about $196 |
| Luffy (061) Parallel Leader | about $42 | about $170 (Dec) | about $80 |
| Booster box | about $240 | about $690 (Jul) | about $632 |
Every single card is between 24% to 58% below its peak! The box is the odd one out, up about 160% in a year and still only 8% off its high.

Our Picks
1. Gol D. Roger Alternate Art: This is clearly the namesake character of the set (we are on record naming Roger the Charizard of One Piece), with 63 copies for sale, so it actually trades. It slid from about $107 in June to about $50, but it has now held between $49 and $54 for about six weeks, which is what a floor looks like. Buy zone: $40–$55 USD for the Roger Alternate Art.
2. Luffy (119) Alternate Art: The solid budget way into the set’s other big chase character. It has sat between $30 and $32 for about ten weeks, with 68 copies for sale. Buy zone: $25–$32 USD for the Luffy Alternate Art.
3. Shanks Wanted Poster (our higher-risk pick): Shanks is one of the hottest characters in the game currently, and this rarer version has only about 32 copies for sale, so not too bad. BUT the catch: it sells roughly once a week, and the “market price” of about $220 is higher than recent actual sales of about $195. Buy zone: $170–$200 USD for the Shanks Wanted Poster. Remember we warned you though, you may need to wait a while for a buyer when you sell.
The Ones We’d Skip (and Why)
All five Manga cards. With 4 to 13 copies each and highly unreliable prices, one bad sale can move the whole market, making the risk too high for the buy-in cost.
Teach Wanted Poster ($190–$200 USD). It doubled since November but is already down about 24% from its August peak, the highs and lows are a bit too unpredictable for our liking in terms of long-term investments. We’d wait a bit to see where it settles.
Luffy (061) Parallel Leader ($80 USD). Down about 53% from its peak and still slowly sliding further down. For context, it was about $155 in July. 2026. A Leader is a card people play in decks, but we’d wait for the slide to stop and get some footing.

Sealed vs Singles at This Age
The box is the big story…kinda…. it’s hard to trade on. It sat near $240 in November 2025, then somehow doubled within about six weeks, hit about $665 by early January, then…. nothing, barely moved for ten months (a range of about $590 to $690). Boxes of older One Piece sets are pricier (wow, what a surprise…): OP-13 at about $405 (12 months old), OP-09 at about $635 (23 months), OP-05 at about $990 (35 months). At OP-13’s current age, OP-09’s box was only $240–$280, so OP-13 is running far more heat (see our OP-13 review). That pattern is tempting, trust us, we understand, but the jump came in one sudden step we can’t explain, and boxes sell only about once a day. For more on the trade-off, see our sealed vs singles debate. We’d put new money in singles.
The Reality Check
Sales are honestly quite thin, look at the Wanted Poster cards. They only sell about once a week, so a single sale can move the price, and the listed “market price” can often lag behind real sales. Due to the thin listings, prices are also built on very few sales, so every range here is a guide, not a promise. Bandai also reuses its stars: OP-13 includes new Gold and Silver Shanks, Roger and Luffy versions of OP-09 cards, so a chase character can get fresh versions later. And one year of history isn’t a long track record.
The TCG Times’ Verdict: Singles, Not the Box, and Nothing Manga
What to buy: Roger Alternate Art, Luffy (119) Alternate Art, and (if you can handle thin sales, remember we’re talking long term) the Shanks Wanted Poster, inside the buy zones above. We’d ladder in over three purchases at least two weeks apart rather than buying everything at once.
What to avoid: the Manga cards, the Teach Wanted Poster and Luffy Leader until they settle, and the box at $630 or more. Think of these more as pulling a winning lotto ticket from a box than something you buy to make money from later.
Our walk-away trigger: if the Roger Alternate Art falls below about $40 USD (it has held $49–$54 for six weeks), or the OP-09 box drops under about $585 (the bottom of its ten-month range), we stop buying. A broken floor usually drags most with it, and that includes the singles with it.
What would change our mind: the Roger Alternate Art climbing back above about $75 while more copies sell each week would tell us demand is returning, and we’d pay the top of the zone.
Disclaimer: The TCG Times is a news and educational platform. All content provided is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as professional financial advice. Trading cards are high-risk, volatile assets. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Always perform your own due diligence before making financial decisions. This article may also contain eBay affiliate links; if you make a purchase through one, The TCG Times may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.



