Pokémon 151: Which Cards Have the Best Long-Term Investment Case?

Pokémon 151 Which Cards Have the Best Long Term Investment Case

Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase through one of these links, The TCG Times may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

How We Judge “Long Term”

The Scoreboard

The whole set is worth roughly $1,600–$1,640 USD across 208 priced cards. Here are the top 10, from our data (our data is pulled directly from TCG Player):

CardRarityPrice nowShare of set value
Charizard ex (199/165)SIR$290–$30018%
Blastoise ex (200/165)SIR$100–$1086%
Venusaur ex (198/165)SIR$85–$905%
Squirtle (170/165)Illustration Rare$77–$825%
Charmander (168/165)Illustration Rare$76–$815%
Zapdos ex (202/165)SIR$66–$724%
Pikachu (173/165)Illustration Rare$55–$604%
Alakazam ex (201/165)SIR$54–$583%
Bulbasaur (166/165)Illustration Rare$51–$563%
Charmeleon (169/165)Illustration Rare$51–$553%

Nineteen cards are worth over $20 USD, 41 are over $5, and only two are over $100. The top 25 cards make up 83% of the value, so the money here is broad, not just a Charizard story (for once). This means we are looking at a safer set to invest in with more points for almost any budget.

The Ride So Far

These are our 4 picks from the last years’ worth of data:

CardNov 2025PeakNowChange since NovOff the peak
Charizard ex SIR$240–$250about $500 (late May)$290–$300+21%−41%
Blastoise ex SIR$75–$80about $225–$230 (early March)$100–$108+34%−54%
Squirtle IR$43–$47about $140 (early March)$77–$82+77%−43%
Charmander IR$52–$56about $155 (mid March)$76–$81+44%−50%

Our Picks

The Ones We’d Skip (and Why)

Venusaur ex SIR ($85–$90 USD). The market has already decided that Venusaur get priced below Blastoise, but in fairness it’s only by about $17. You’re paying near-Blastoise money for the lesser-demand starter.

Zapdos ex SIR ($66–$72 USD). We went through our three tests and couldn’t find one it generally wins outright. It’s a nice card, not a conviction card. Keep this one for yourself; it’s not going to really make you cash.

The Mew ex trio ($22–$27 USD each). Mew is the face of the set, but there are three different Mew ex versions in it (Ultra Rare, Hyper Rare and the metal card). Think means the scarcity gets diluted, and so does the investment concept.

Charizard ex Ultra Rare ($35–$38 USD). We know it looks like a bargain next to the SIR, but in all honesty, it isn’t: it’s a lower rarity tier with far more copies out there, so it passes character demand but fails the scarcity test.

Sealed vs Singles at This Age

Sealed has already had its run, and the run was solid. The 151 Elite Trainer Box is about $490–$495 USD against a $54.99 USD retail price, which is around 9x the RRP! The booster bundle is about $166 USD, which is around 6x the RRP, and a single booster pack is about $26 USD. Compare that with ME01’s box at about 1.9x after 13 months, or the compact Mega sets at around 1.1x. Nostalgia is already in the sealed price. Singles still have a character premium you can buy in a controlled way. Now consider this: for the price of one bundle, you could own the Blastoise ex SIR and one starter Illustration Rare inside our buy zones (about $150–$180 USD combined) and skip the pack gamble entirely.

The Reality Check

We gotta mention it, this is one year of history, not a decade. Every pick is still slightly bleeding from its spring peak (down 41% to 54%), and we can’t promise the slide has finished, it’s impossible for us to truly know. A three-year-old set has already had its nostalgia run, and 6–9x sealed multiples mean the market knows it. We should also note that the gap between market price and lowest listing means you’ll need to check condition on every card. And reprint risk is the one thing we can’t price: we couldn’t verify a confirmed 151 reprint, but The Pokémon Company has surprised the hobby before. We do find it highly unlikely though.

The TCG Times’ Verdict: Buy the Trio, Skip the Hype, Don’t Overpay for the Dragon

Our walk-away trigger: if a 151 reprint is confirmed (it isn’t and we doubt it’ll ever happen), or the Charizard ex SIR breaks below about $235 USD (the floor of its pre-rally range) and keeps on sliding, we stop adding. A move through that floor would mean the 30th-anniversary premium has fully unwound and nostalgia demand is weaker than what the data says.

What would change our mind: a Charizard ex SIR that holds $290–$300 USD for a month while Blastoise stops falling would make us comfortable paying close to the top. And also lowest listings sliding while sales volume dries up would make us pull back.

Disclaimer: The TCG Times is a news and educational platform. All content provided is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as professional financial advice. Trading cards are high-risk, volatile assets. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Always perform your own due diligence before making financial decisions. This article may also contain eBay affiliate links; if you make a purchase through one, The TCG Times may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *